---
title: Membership, CRM, and Newsletters
date: 2025-12-27
summary: Tools for managing contacts, memberships, donations, and communications. When your member relationships live on your infrastructure, your community's most valuable asset stays under your control.
draft: True
featureImageCaption: "Photo by [Melanie Deziel](https://unsplash.com/@storyfuel) on [Unsplash](https://unsplash.com/photos/U33fHryBYBU) (Unsplash License)"
---

Communities exist through relationships. The contacts, members, donors, and supporters who make up your community are your most valuable asset.

Without good systems, this relationship data lives in scattered spreadsheets, personal email accounts, and people's heads. When key volunteers leave, contact histories and donor relationships disappear. Communication becomes chaotic—duplicate outreach, missed renewals, frustrated members.

Commercial platforms like Mailchimp, HubSpot, and Salesforce solve these problems, but at a cost: per-contact pricing that scales with your community, data stored on corporate servers, and dependency on companies whose priorities may not align with yours.

Open source alternatives offer the same capabilities while keeping your community's relationships under your control.

---

## Why This Matters for Communities

### The Cost Reality

A nonprofit with 25,000 contacts might pay $300+ per month for Mailchimp alone. Add CRM features and the costs climb further.

Self-hosted Listmonk on a $10/month server plus Amazon SES ($0.10 per 1,000 emails) costs under $50/month total—an 80%+ savings.

Over years, these savings compound. Every dollar not spent on subscription fees is a dollar available for actual community work.

### Data Sovereignty

Your member data is your community's institutional memory. On commercial platforms:
- Your data lives on their servers, subject to their terms
- Platforms can change terms, raise prices, or shut down features
- Data portability is often limited
- Third-party data sharing feeds advertising profiles

Self-hosted tools mean:
- Complete data sovereignty—data never leaves your infrastructure
- Full export capability—your data, your format, anytime
- Simplified compliance—you're the sole data controller
- No surveillance—no behavioral tracking for advertising

### Mission Alignment

When your member data lives on a commercial platform, you're paying rent on your own relationships. Every dollar spent on subscription fees flows to distant shareholders rather than your mission.

Organizations that advocate for community control should use tools that embody those values.

### Sustainability

Commercial platforms get acquired, pivot, or shut down. Mailchimp was acquired by Intuit. Constant Contact has changed hands multiple times. Each transition brings pricing changes and policy shifts.

Open source software can't be "acquired" away from you. The code belongs to everyone. Your community's institutional memory shouldn't depend on a startup's runway or a corporation's quarterly earnings.

---

## Real-World Examples

### CiviCRM

Used by major organizations worldwide:
- **Wikimedia Foundation**: Donor management for Wikipedia fundraising
- **Amnesty International**: Member management across multiple chapters
- **Electronic Frontier Foundation**: Supporter engagement and action alerts
- **Creative Commons**: Community and donor management
- **Australian Greens**: Political party membership management

11,000+ active installations manage tens of millions of contact records globally.

### Listmonk

Growing rapidly among technical and privacy-conscious organizations:
- 15,000+ GitHub stars
- Single binary, extremely lightweight
- Can handle millions of subscribers
- Popular with developer communities and open source projects

### Mautic

200,000+ installations claimed:
- Marketing agencies using it as white-label solution
- Educational institutions for student recruitment
- Nonprofits for donor cultivation
- Political campaigns for voter outreach

---

## Choosing the Right Tool

### CiviCRM: The Nonprofit Powerhouse

Best for nonprofits and civic organizations needing comprehensive constituent management.

**Strengths**: Purpose-built for nonprofits; comprehensive features (contacts, contributions, memberships, events, mailings, cases, campaigns, grants); deep CMS integrations (WordPress, Drupal, Joomla); large extension ecosystem.

**Considerations**: Steeper learning curve; requires CMS; best with technical support or training.

### Listmonk: The Newsletter Specialist

Best for organizations primarily needing newsletter and email list management.

**Strengths**: Blazingly fast and resource-efficient; simple, focused feature set; handles millions of subscribers; easy to deploy.

**Considerations**: Newsletter/mailing only—not a full CRM; requires technical comfort for setup.

### Mautic: The Marketing Platform

Best for organizations wanting full marketing automation capabilities.

**Strengths**: Full marketing automation; visual campaign builder; landing pages and forms; lead scoring and nurturing; multi-channel (email, SMS, web).

**Considerations**: More complex than simpler tools; resource-intensive; requires ongoing maintenance.

### Odoo Community: The Business Suite

Best for organizations needing CRM integrated with broader business operations.

**Strengths**: Complete business suite (CRM is one module of many); unified data across sales, inventory, accounting; massive app ecosystem.

**Considerations**: Can be overkill for CRM-only needs; some features push toward Enterprise edition.

---

## Open Source Options

| Project | Description |
|:--------|:------------|
| [CiviCRM](https://civicrm.org) | Comprehensive constituent management for nonprofits. Contacts, donations, memberships, events, and more. <br><small>📊 11,000+ installations. Used by Wikimedia, Amnesty, EFF.</small> <br><small>📦 [GitHub](https://github.com/civicrm/civicrm-core) · AGPL-3.0</small> |
| [Listmonk](https://listmonk.app) | High-performance newsletter and mailing list manager. <br><small>📊 15,000+ GitHub stars. Handles millions of subscribers.</small> <br><small>📦 [GitHub](https://github.com/knadh/listmonk) · AGPL-3.0</small> |
| [Mautic](https://www.mautic.org) | Full marketing automation platform with campaigns, landing pages, and lead scoring. <br><small>📊 200,000+ installations claimed.</small> <br><small>📦 [GitHub](https://github.com/mautic/mautic) · GPL-3.0</small> |
| [Odoo Community](https://www.odoo.com/page/community) | Complete business suite including CRM, integrated with sales, inventory, and accounting. <br><small>📊 7M+ users across editions.</small> <br><small>📦 [GitHub](https://github.com/odoo/odoo) · LGPL-3.0</small> |

---

## Feature Comparison

| Feature | CiviCRM | Listmonk | Mautic | Odoo |
|:--------|:--------|:---------|:-------|:-----|
| Contact management | Excellent | Basic | Good | Good |
| Email campaigns | Good | Excellent | Excellent | Good |
| Donation tracking | Excellent | No | No | Via modules |
| Membership management | Excellent | No | No | Via modules |
| Marketing automation | Basic | No | Excellent | Good |
| Event management | Good | No | No | Via modules |
| Best for | Nonprofits | Newsletters | Marketing | Full business |

---

## The Bigger Picture

Your members trusted you with their information—not a Silicon Valley advertising company. Self-hosted tools mean member data never leaves your control. There's no behavioral profiling, no third-party data sharing, no surveillance capitalism built on your community's relationships.

Using open source community tools isn't just about saving money. It's about building capacity. When your organization understands and controls its own technology, you're not just a customer—you're a participant in a global movement of communities helping communities.

These tools are maintained by communities of users who share your values. When CiviCRM or Mautic evolves, it's because organizations like yours shaped that evolution.

Your community's relationships are too important to rent. Own them.
